In Defence of the Em-Dash
Something I’m hearing more and more from clients is, “Can we get rid of the em-dashes? It makes it look like I’ve used AI.”
And, let’s face it, in some contexts, that’s not entirely wrong.
If I’m reading a piece of short-form writing—a Facebook post, a LinkedIn update, a marketing email—I’m not expecting em-dashes.
Why Em Dashes Have Become a “Tell”
So, why do they turn up? Well, in part, it’s because AIs are trained to write using long-form text: books, articles, journals. Those training texts were written by people who knew when and how to wield the em-dash. And—here’s the important bit—they were written before people started trying to avoid the em-dash.
But the other side of it is that em-dashes create a sort of ‘coziness’. They’re a way to signal intimacy, insight, or vulnerability without actually having to earn it. And so, we see it everywhere: half-formed ideas, faux confessions, manufactured “thinking aloud”. And yes, a lot of that is machine-generated.
But the em-dash isn’t the problem. The format is.
Short-Form Writing vs Long-Form Thinking
Short-form writing is performative. It rewards speed, recognisability, and pattern-matching. The moment a stylistic habit becomes widespread, it turns into a trope—and once something becomes a trope, it becomes suspect. The em-dash just happens to be the punctuation currently wearing the blame.
Long-form writing plays by different rules.
When someone sits down to read your article, essay, or book, they’re not looking for slogans. They’re inviting you to share your thought process. They expect nuance, digression, clarification, and the occasional doubling back. They don’t just want to read what you think; they want to know how you got there.
And that’s where the em-dash comes into its own.
Because the em-dash mimics how we actually think and speak. Real thought doesn’t arrive in perfectly stacked propositions, each one neatly supporting the next. It arrives in bursts, revisions, and interruptions. We start a sentence one way, realize something mid-stream, adjust, qualify, or sharpen the point—and then we carry on.
What Em Dashes Actually Do on the Page
Without em-dashes, writing tends to drift toward the philosophical. Each idea laid carefully on top of the last. No distractions. No visible process. A clear, immaculate through-line of thought.
That may be exactly what you want.
But if it isn’t—if you want your reader to feel like they’re listening to a real person rather than absorbing a conclusion—then the em-dash is almost inevitable.
The em-dash allows you to acknowledge the complexity of your ideas without stopping dead. It lets you add a late-arriving thought without pretending it was always there—which can be invaluable.
To see the difference, consider this short passage from my book Just Sign Here! (written long before LLMs were a thing):
With em-dashes
It’s an approach that works well—if it didn’t, you can be sure those advertisers wouldn’t be doing it—but it’s much more effective at lower price points, and it tends to get you clients for one-off transactions: once the pain is gone, they don’t need you.
Now, let’s remove the dashes. First, we could replace them with parentheses:
Without em-dashes (version 1: parentheses)
It’s an approach that works well (if it didn’t, you can be sure those advertisers wouldn’t be doing it), but it’s much more effective at lower price points, and it tends to get you clients for one-off transactions: once the pain is gone, they don’t need you.
I don’t know about you, but to me, those parentheses really get in the way. The reader has to slow down and re-map the sentence. What was a confident aside now feels like an unwelcome interruption.
So let’s try a different approach to eliminating the em-dash: breaking the text up into multiple sentences.
Without em-dashes (version 2: broken apart)
It’s an approach that works well. If it didn’t, you can be sure those advertisers wouldn’t be doing it. However, it’s much more effective at lower price points, and it tends to get you clients for one-off transactions. Once the pain is gone, they don’t need you.
We’re back to clear and correct. But it’s fundamentally changed.
The original text allowed you to hold the concession and the critique in your head at the same time. You could take the big idea in with a single pass, and your brain gently skimmed over the aside. In this modified version, the aside gets its own sentence. It feels important—as important as the real main idea—and that makes it harder to parse what your real message is.
Another example, also from Just Sign Here!
With em-dashes:
Most professionals don’t struggle with sales because they lack confidence—they struggle because they’re trying to sound like someone they’re not. Somewhere along the way, they’ve learned a version of “professionalism” that strips out warmth, curiosity, and doubt—and then they wonder why conversations stall.
Without em-dashes:
Most professionals don’t struggle with sales because they lack confidence; they struggle because they’re trying to sound like someone they’re not. Somewhere along the way, they’ve learned a version of professionalism that strips out warmth, curiosity, and doubt. They then wonder why conversations stall.
Nothing is wrong with the second version. It’s clear. It’s correct. It’s tidy.
But it’s flatter.
The first version reads like someone thinking through the idea as they explain it, realizing, mid-sentence, what the real problem is, and adjusting course. The second feels like a summary written after the thinking was already done.
That distinction matters if you’re writing for your readers rather than referees.
Of course, I’m not saying you should spray em-dashes across the page. Overused, they become a verbal tic. A way of avoiding commitment. A substitute for structure rather than a support for it.
Good writers edit their em-dashes ruthlessly. Each one has to earn its place. In the case of Just Sign Here!, I just checked, and I had 320 em-dashes in 62,000 words: one or two on virtually every page. And I started with a lot more before I edited!
The Real Difference Between AI Writing and Human Writing
And this brings us to the real ‘tell’ of AI writing.
It isn’t punctuation.
It’s risk.
AI uses em-dashes cautiously. The interruptions are neat, predictable, and consequence-free. They add colour without altering the direction of the thought. Nothing truly changes mid-sentence.
Human writers interrupt themselves differently. When a human uses an em-dash well, it’s because something important arrived late—a clarification, a correction, a narrowing of intent—and the sentence had to adapt on the fly. That interruption reshapes what comes next.
In other words, the dash isn’t decorative. It’s structural. And that kind of interruption can’t be faked without risking awkwardness, imbalance, or failure—which is exactly why it feels human when it works.
Banning the em-dash in the name of sounding human is a category error. In long-form writing, the em-dash isn’t a crutch. It’s evidence that a real mind is at work—thinking, adjusting, and inviting the reader along for the ride.
An Aside
Just for kicks, I put this article through an AI-checker. Apparently, the phrase “half-formed ideas” is an AI tell, so are “which can be invaluable,” “with parentheses,” “unwelcome distraction,” and—the real kicker—”original text” is apparently 900x more common in AI writing than in human writing.
Well, I can assure you my human instructed me to tell you I’m not a robot.
Bleep bloop!